Smart Operations are a necessary part of Smart Energy. Maybe GBXML is, too.

It is easy to think we are playing the end game, but we are really working on the early stages of smart energy.

Smart grids may end at the edges of the grid, they may know no bounds, i.e., ZigBee and SEP, or they may end at the meter. Beyond the meter may be a collection of dumb systems, a minimal collection of defined systems with defined responses, or a micro-grid with its own economy, and own dynamics. I think that every node a microgrid is the future.

I was pulled back to thinking about buildings as I prepared to speak at the AHR show in Orlando next week, and by an announcement about an upcoming seminar on GBXML (GB = Green Building). GBXML is a format designed for the exchange of engineering information, particularly that related to energy use and energy efficiency, during the design process. GBXML may be the key to understanding microgrids in buildings.

The challenge when we treat the end nodes as micro-grids is categorizing and measuring the services they provide. These may be relatively clear in the data center, but even there, understanding HVAC support services is relatively obscure to the IT operator. Going a step further and treating the data center as the district energy center for thermal distribution is hard to understand, harder to account for, and therefore difficult for most enterprises to work with. What are the services in the end nodes?

So, after a building has been partially renovated a few times, and has three EMS (energy management systems), each managing a dozen zones, what effect is there on which part of the business when load is shed in a particular way? Which departments, or tenants, are even affected? Do tenants have QOS agreements, and if so, how are they affected.

Full-fledged BIM (Building Information Model), as defined in NBIMS and BuildingSmart, is too fat, too heavy to use in everyday operations. GBXML is a light-weight one-off of the IFCs in BuildingSmart. It was developed to model energy use, and to exchange energy models within buildings. GBXML includes formal definitions of geometries and spaces, and common models for the components of the energy using systems in buildings. It might just be the map between the design, the operations, and the services. GBXML might just be BIM-Light.

Somewhere between the intriguing, but not yet all that useful Microsoft Hohm and Google Energy, there needs to be a path for buildings as service providers. Understanding services in buildings requires understanding tenants, and their purposes. Perhaps Building Service Profiles link to the spaces in the light-weight BIM (GBXML) and therefore to the tenant services.

Energy profiles linked to the Building Service Profiles, then, become the links between Demand Response and graphical, tenant aware interfaces for building operations.

Last week, I received an announcement of a GBXML seminar in building design (http://www.gbxml.org/events.php). So far, efforts such as LEEDS have not yet delivered on the vision of sustainable energy-efficient high-performance buildings. The unhappy truth today is that most "green" buildings are poor energy performers within a couple years of delivery. Commissioning is a one-time act with no visible links to ongoing operations. Maybe using GBXML to both define the services of buildings and to operate/visualize their operations will not only enable stronger DR, but will lead to better every-day operations.

I am convinced that long term models for distributed energy, and for rapid innovations in energy use, come in this area. All the early incentives of DR, and the early visualizations of Google Energy and Hohm, are merely the tip of wedge for DER and smart energy in the end nodes. We need an interface between design, construction, operations, and smart energy. GBXML may be the most important enabler of net zero, near grid, and off-grid facilities. It may be what we need to apply the facilities capability management approaches pioneered by the Coast Guard to the policy-based net zero security and survivability of the NZ Army base.

I recommend that you check out the seminar on GBXML if you are interested in the real potential of smart energy.

body>

The Fourth Amendment and Smart Grids

If we are not careful, smart grids are in direct collision with the bill of rights. Some smart grid activities define or enable business practices for balancing energy supply and demand. There is a direct link between commonly accepted business practices and some definitions of our constitutional rights. With the best of intentions, we may be casually removing significant barriers to some of our most cherished freedoms.

The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution is the part of the Bill of Rights which guards against unreasonable searches and seizures. During the American Revolution, British forces made extensive use of writs of assistance, a sort of general search warrant that could be extended and used without ongoing review. In response, the Fourth Amendment created a standard whereby government searches must be issues only on a discovery of probable cause, and specifically limited in location and as to the matters being searched for, based on specific information supplied to a court.

The Fourth Amendment is the most explicit source of any support for privacy that I can find in the Constitution.

Dr Orin Kerr is one of the most respected legal voices on Fourth Amendment issues. Dr Kerr blogged this week on the relationship between technology, common practices, and developing standards for reasonable search (see reference below). Specifically, Dr Kerr was exploring the ten year old Supreme Court ruling in Kyllo vs. United States that defines the limits of police use of high technology in warrantless searches.

In cartoon form (IANAL), police scanned houses with some sort of IR scanning system and noted a hot spot in the attic. From the hot spot, they deduced that the defendant was growing marijuana under grow lights in his attic. Kyllo asserted that this was a prohibited search under the 4^th amendment. The question was, in effect, is a non-intrusive search using high tech an unreasonable search. Clearly, if Kyllo had been growing the marijuana in his front yard, there would have been no dispute when police noticed this when on routine patrol. Previous rulings had stated that police fly-overs are legal searches because non-police could fly over the property and spot the plants; the property owner has no reasonable expectation of privacy applied to aerial views of his property.

In this case, the search was ruled unconstitutional; Kyllo won. The Supreme Court adopted a test designed to let the result change with social practice: “when . . . the Government uses a device that is not in general public use, to explore details of the home that would previously have been unknowable without physical intrusion, the surveillance is a “search” and is presumptively unreasonable without a warrant.” Because infrared temperature sensing was not in “general public use,” the thermal imaging was a “search” that required a warrant.

Dr. Kerr was blogging on whether under this standard, the search in Kyllo was still prohibited. Remote infrared temperature-sensing has become quite common in a wide range of applications. I heard an ad on the radio yesterday for a remote home thermometer enabling mom to take a sleeping child’s temperature from the door without waking the child. Thermal images of houses to reveal gaps in insulation have become common; many utilities will pay for them as part of energy efficiency efforts. The question was, then, is this high tech device now considered to be in in “general public use,” and if so, can the police use it without a warrant without violating the Fourth amendment.

And so, at last, I loop back to smart grids.

Some business practices we are defining, particularly in what we are calling Managed Energy, can routinely monitor the activity of every device in a home. If we establish these practices as general practice, have we eliminated any Fourth Amendment shield against the use of the same techniques by police?

Analysis of electrical power consumption reveals more than you might guess. Research a decade ago explored what engineers could learn from these signals. One anomaly occurred almost every day in a home somewhere between a half hour and two hours after the owners left each day. Further research determined that the family dog waited each day until it was sure that its owners were really gone for the day—and then climbed onto the warm waterbed. They were detecting the change in the pattern of water heater use. Further research demonstrated an ability to distinguish how much activity was on that waterbed…

When we define business practices for the smart grid, we are doing more than solving a a difficult engineering problem. We may be creating practices that re-define our precious constitutional rights. Privacy is more than a best business practice for smart grids.

Bio-batteries, Bio-Generation, and Pervasive Energy

I am always intrigued by bio-batteries and bio-generation. Every now and then, I read a report, or talk to someone in passing, whose work is far off the beaten electrical engineering path. I am always especially interested when I learn that one of these companies has been funded, meaning they have been able to demonstrate something working, even if only once for one person. Most of them will never be able to provide grid-scale energy; but I think that will not be able to solve our energy problems at grid scale, unless we change our policies that guide our energy choices, and are policies that constrain our siting and construction.

Coal-based algal diesel was our best shot at grid-scale bio-energy. The process feeds nearly-pure oxygen into a high efficiency coal plant, produce nearly pure carbon dioxide as waste. This carbon dioxide then supercharges the growth of enhanced algae that produce compounds that can be made into biodiesel. The carbon would be captured into the fuel, the algae would release oxygen. The first scale trial of this approach was shouted down by the no-coal sloganistas and the anti-genetic engineering luddites. So much for reliable clean generation and energy independence.

I am more interested in local bio-generation and bio-storage. To me, pervasive energy is the natural outcome of smart energy. Pervasive energy achieves stability through diversity of technology as well as of location. Bio-energy adds another source of technology diversity.

A year ago, I ate breakfast with an electrical engineer who had flown in to meet his venture funding, and to review his progress. He was working with a biologist to coax electrons off of bacteria. Many of the most essential activities of bacteria involve electron pumps across cell membranes. Many processes are an attempt to get rid of excess electrons. The smell of swamp gasses in in part due to the ability of sulfur to accept easily another electron. We experience the strong odors of sulfur compounds in the strong smell of onions and garlic, due to compounds (mercaptans) that use sulfur to scoop up electrons and keep their sweet flesh from rotting. Bacterial generation convinces soil bacteria to get rid of electrons onto special electrodes to generate a current that can power low power lights., Bacterial generation is not grid scale; you will not use it to light up your town. If you have damp soil, you might use it to light your front walk, or to power emergency lights in stairwells.

Down east here in Carolina, a hog farmer has created a bio-based district energy plant. He tented his waste lagoon to capture the methane gas. He uses the methane to heat greenhouses of winter tomatoes. He cools the flue gases and pipes the carbon-dioxide rich mix into the greenhouses to accelerate tomato growth. The use of this energy on his micro-district is more valuable than selling to the grid.

I recently read a report of a battery "based on the biology of electric eels". The report claimed that a new company is within a year of commercial batteries for cell phones. I have no idea what process these batteries are based on; I suspect that the publicist-author did not understand it either. For now, I have to be content thinking about, as William Cox quipped, a cell phone that re-charges when dropped in the toilet.

Speaking of toilets, humans produce large amounts of materials of use for the energy engineer. By happy chance, these materials are already located where we can use them for distributed energy. I have written before about the report from Ohio University of using full strength human urine as a source of hydrogen for fuel cells. The cartoons, of course, suggest of unconventional attempts to fill a car's gas tank in the middle of the night. The reality suggests an efficient material to use converting local generation, whether solar or wind, to hydrogen for later use.

The North American grid used to be reliable. We have used up its safety margins. We are, by policy, replacing reliable generation (coal, nuclear) with un-reliable generation (wind, solar, et al.). We cannot solve those problems within the grid. The North American Power Grid will probably never be as reliable again.

We will supplement that reliability, though, with a diverse set of energy sources and energy storage systems in our homes and offices. Some of these storage systems will be metal-acid batteries, and thermal storage, and even compressed air. But some of these supplements will be strictly biological.

Distributed Energy Grids can use Diverse Energy Storage

But there’s no way to store energy, he said. What he should have said is that there are few ways to store energy at grid scale. Grids, and microgrids, have two approaches to storing energy. They can store it in something that produces electricity, or they can store it in any format that provides a service to its customers. The closer we get to the end users of energy, the more options we have to store energy. The most critical short term goal of smart grids might be to transfer as many incentives for energy storage to the end nodes of the grid as possible as soon as possible.

Very few of us want electricity—we want instead to have a modern life-style. This means we want ready access to sanitary services, whether clean water or working waste disposal. We want light, and heat (or cooling). We want our appliances to provide whatever services we bought them for. Digital electronics provide us with the most direct conversion of electricity to desirable service, but even there we may be able to store services.

Behind every meter there is a microgrid, which exists to supply the wants of its customers. The customers of transmission and distribution grids only want electricity, and they want a lot, so these grids are limited in how they can store energy. Any storage that these grids do use, must be big enough to support the transmission or distribution scale of operations. For example, pump storage, wherein water is pumped up in the air, and used for hydro-generation later, is a very efficient way to store the energy in electricity for later use. Transmission-scale pump storage, though, must be as big as a small lake. There are a limited number of locations to place a lake with a down-hill water supply where filling and draining the lake is an acceptable option. We may have used all of them in North America already.

There are not many more options for distribution scale storage in traditional local microgrids. Non-traditional microgrids, however, distribute more than electrical energy. District energy grids distribute thermal energy, whether in the form of heat (steam) or of cooling (chilled water). These systems can pre-cool (or pre-heat, although this is less common) water for distribution. Thermal storage lets district energy microgrids shift energy use to off-peak hours. In a modern transactive grid, such shifting can be part of demand response. Microgrids with significant thermal storage may be able to run entirely on site-based alternative energy during peak hours. They may be able to store off-peak generation converted to thermal energy.

Non-energy utilities have their own grids supported by the distribution grid. A significant service in cities is the supply of water, and water pressure. This is done by pumping water high into the air, using energy-intensive pumps. Water towers can easily become locations for energy storage, off-loading electrical use until when energy is cheap, and the pumps can run inexpensively. This local pump storage is not used to generate electricity, but within its limits is an effective way to shift energy use to times when energy is cheaper and more plentiful.

When the microgrid gets down to the size of a single commercial building or home, all sorts of energy storage options become available, if only we do not confine ourselves to electrical storage. High rise buildings pump water to so toilets will flush. Thermal storage can be in basements or rooftops. Some data center strategies could even be considered to be storing up business process for use later.